*Editorial Note: We apologize for the lack of updates over the course of the summer! We've been extremely busy in-store and also with the many new features over on the Maine Running Facebook page. However, now that we've settled into the groove, we should be seeing more regular posting around these parts, including continuing the Maine Athlete Feature series, the Medical Professional Series, gear reviews, and much much more!*
As an athlete, I use and abuse watches.
No, seriously: I've beaten the beejezus out of every watch I've ever owned. Whether it's a Timex band that I've managed to sweat through and corroded the rubber, or destroying the face of another watch, or popping the buttons off of something else...you get the picture. If it can survive me, it can probably survive anything.
That also said, I loathe devices that serve only one purpose. A running watch that can only be used for running? Sorry, not going to work for me. A bike computer? Nope, sorry, needs to be able to keep track of multiple things. No, the device I want needs to be able to serve every purpose. It needs to be one-stop shopping for all of my racing and training exploits.
Enter: the
Garmin Forerunner 910XT.
 |
| Garmin Forerunner 910XT in multisport mode: Image courtesy of Garmin. |
The Tech Babble
To really get into what the 910 is all about, you really need to re-trace your history of GPS-enabled athletic devices.
The original device was a co-branded unit from
Timex and Garmin: Timex made the watch unit for everything, and then there was a separate arm unit that received the GPS signal that was made by Garmin. This pairing wasn't incredibly resilient nor user-friendly. However, each learned from one another: Garmin on the watch side of things, Timex on the GPS side.
Garmin wound up releasing a multitude of devices: the Garmin Forerunner 201 and 301, for those keeping track at home. They looked, well, like bricks. Nor were they incredibly durable or user-friendly. Water resistant? Nope. But they allowed you to track your training, and in the case of the 300 series, it allowed multiple sport modes.
Garmin then further updated the watches with the 205, 305, and later the run specific 405. The 305 is of most importance to the story, as it was truly their multisport watch. However, it still was not truly water resistant. Although you will still see some triathletes toe the swim line with the 305 with success, it really isn't designed for it. The 405, meanwhile, introduced the touch-bezel to the equation. (That sound you heard was many runners groaning in frustration with their 405s.)
The 305, however, became the 310: the first fully swimmable Garmin. This meant more than a moderate rain would still be fine. It still retained the brick-like looks of the 305, but it was finally becoming a little lighter, and a little easier to use still. But it didn't sync well with a lot of other devices that many athletes use, despite speaking the ANT+ language (think: Bluetooth for athletic stuff). And the font face looked directly out of a 1993 Oldsmobile Cutlass Ciera. (How do I know, you ask? I owned one.)
This brings us all the way forward to the modern 910, pictured above. It is not nearly as large as some of the earlier devices, despite the rather large face on the watch. It is much lighter than previous iterations in this product line as well. It fits on numerous wrist sizes, and you can even switch that band out for a smaller one, if you prefer.
This is a watch that can and will do just about everything. I'm relatively positive that if you pushed the correct button combination on the 910, you'd be able to have it cook you dinner.
Now, with that in mind, let's delve into what it's actually designed to do:
There are four distinct training modes available to you: swimming, biking, running, and multisport mode. The first three are self-explanatory, and we'll delve into those in a bit. The multisport mode, on the other hand, is a little bit more complex. Multisport mode allows you to transition from different other modes just by pushing the lap button. So, say you're racing a triathlon: you can have it set to seamlessly move from swim mode, to bike mode, to run mode, and also have it factor in transitions.
Now that we've looked at multisport mode, let's break down what the swim mode, bike mode, and run mode can do for you.
Swimming
In an improvement on the 310, the 910 allows you to use the watch while doing indoor swims. It has a completely separate mode for it. So when you power the watch on, and go to select swimming, it will ask you: open-water swim (activates the GPS), or pool swim. If you select pool swim, it will then ask you what type of pool you are swimming in: 25-yards, 25 meters, or 50 meters. (For those wondering: the Riverton Pool in Portland is a 25 meter pool. Almost all of the YMCAs that are local are 25 yard pools.)
Setting the correct distance is important, as the watch can actually count laps and keep track of distance for you. It even recognizes what swim stroke you are swimming: freestyle, backstroke, butterfly, and breaststroke are all recognized. The 910 will also calculate an efficiency score for you based on the number of strokes you took, distance per stroke, and the time it took for you to complete a lap. It can really help you hone in on what an ideal stroke rate is for you personally, as it's different for each person.
A note about this swim mode, though: the distance is based on the watch travelling through the water in a swim stroke. It will NOT calculate distance for kick sets. So if you have a set of drills that you're doing, or a set of kicking ahead of you, you'll want to just run off the pace clock rather than using the watch.
With open-water swim mode, it will calculate distance based off of the GPS. You lose the swim efficiency scores, as well as the recognition of swim stroke. Previous iterations of swim GPS files were very, very patchy at best. This, however, really smooths the file out. As an example, here's my swim from
Rev3 Old Orchard Beach:
 |
| Yeah, I know: I can't sight worth crap. But hey, I swam fast (for me!) |
As with any of the modes, the screens are fully customizable: you can see whatever details you'd like. I personally opt for total swim time, total swim distance, and pace as the three data fields when in an open-water swim. Why? Well, I'm not going to stop and look at it while swimming. So having fewer data fields that give me the quick hits when I'm sighting or when I'm exiting the water is better than having more information available. Just need the facts and keep on plugging!
Bike Mode
Here's where the 910 makes another vast leap over it's predecessor: the ease in which you can add accessories to it. Say, for example, you have a cadence sensor on your bike. Well, if it speaks ANT+, it will sync up with the 910. Same thing with powermeters, or magnets, or...you get the idea.
I tend to opt for four data fields when training: time, speed, distance, and heart-rate. One of the new features for the 910 is the ability to customize numerous screens. The way I use this is feature is when I have an interval session on the bike. Rather than changing the normal screen that I have set described above, there's up to four other screens that I can scroll through and customize. So my second bike screen has lap time, lap distance, and instant speed. This gives me the numbers I need to work through interval sessions and the corresponding recovery period. Then when I get done with the intervals, I can toggle back to the regular screen that I prefer.
Run Mode
If you've ever used a GPS-based device before, nothing here will shock you. The biggest thing that you'll notice, again, is the ability to toggle between numerous screens of data, and customize them all.
One of the other run features that I like on this particular unit is the auto-lap feature. You can set this to auto-lap whenever you see fit. Doing walk-run intervals? Great! You can use a time feature to do so, and for it to capture each pace. Want to know your mile splits later on? You can do, that, too. As an example, I had mine set to auto-split every mile for the
Trail to Ale 10K.
 |
| Positive split, anyone? Still a new 10K PR... |
The one gripe that I have about the watch has to be the instant pace feature. Unfortunately, it is extremely jumpy. It's not nearly as smoothed out as previous watches that I have used, including the older Garmin 305 and the
Nike SportWatch. It's worst if you are under tree cover. It'll wind up recording the correct overall pace, etc. but the instant pace that you see on the watch does not seem to ever match up unless you have a direct link to the eyes in the sky.
This is one of the main reasons that I found the lap average pace function to be so critical; it tends to paint a better picture of the effort than does instant pace. However, it's nice from time to time to check to make sure that you're hitting the targets that you are looking for. It has steadily improved with each software update, and a new firmware was released just recently, that would suggest that Garmin is continually working to improve the instant pace function.
Uploading Data: Garmin Connect, and Exporting Elsewhere
This is another improvement over previous Garmin devices: how it syncs up with your computer.
There is a wireless USB stick that plugs into your computer. If your device is powered on when you walk on by the computer...instant upload! Automatically signs into
Garmin Connect, which is where all of the above file information came from.
When you go to look at your data post-activity, here's what you'll see:
 |
| Brief overview; click to expand the size of the image. |
You'll be able to see your splits, route breakdown, etc. Very cool.
Now, what if you use other software? As an example, I'm an avid user of
TrainingPeaks. Well, they've come up with an auto-upload feature for the 910 as well, that takes your files and imports them into TrainingPeaks for you. No more exporting from Garmin Connect into TrainingPeaks; instead, it goes from the device into TrainingPeaks and away you go.
Pretty darn seamless.
A Note on GPS Accuracy
Some of you may notice that the Garmin file for Trail to Ale denotes a total slightly less than 6.2 miles. This is well within the range of "normal" variance for GPS devices. As another example, my Garmin file for the
Boston Marathon says I ran 26.5 miles. All of my Garmin files for the Rev3 events I did read longer than 70.3 miles. What gives?
For certified courses, the key for them is that the course must be measured to
at least the distance. So, they actually all tend to be just slightly longer than the measure. Couple that with the about .03 mile variance that can happen with any GPS device...and well, you're bound to have some inaccuracies somewhere.
But as a training tool, I find a Garmin file extremely valuable, to see how the body is adapting to the training load that you are subjecting it to. You can find out just how well you're handling your training, and be able to avoid common undertraining or overtraining issues.
The Verdict
This is, by far, the most intuitive GPS device I've used. It gives you a wealth of data that is unparalleled, but at the same time is incredibly simple to use. I can't imagine anything else standing up to it. So if you're looking for a one-stop device for your running or multisport needs, this is it.
$399.99 without heart-rate, $449.99 with heart-rate monitor
Available: Now